A service agreement explains what the parties promise. A useful service level explains how they will know those promises are being kept. The best scorecards are short, balanced, and built from reliable data.
Separate KPIs from service levels
A KPI shows performance over time. A service level sets an expectation for a defined measure. Not every KPI needs a penalty. Some should first establish a baseline.
Core manpower KPIs
Recruitment and deployment
- Fill rate: deployed divided by approved requested headcount.
- Qualified endorsement rate.
- Deployment lead time from complete request to start.
Attendance and continuity
- Attendance and on-time arrival.
- Absence notification.
- Replacement response and successful replacement time.
- Open post hours.
Payroll and administration
- Time-record approval timeliness.
- Payroll accuracy and correction turnaround.
- SOA accuracy and dispute resolution.
Quality, support, and safety
Use measures the parties can influence, such as accuracy, report timeliness, training, safety actions, concern resolution, and early retention. Do not assign the provider full responsibility for stockouts, downtime, or client process changes.
Write every service level precisely
Define measure, formula, data source, owner, frequency, target, exclusions, escalation, and review process. 'Replace workers quickly' is not measurable. Identify when the clock starts, roles covered, business hours, approvals, access requirements, and successful completion.
Targets should reflect role difficulty, site, shift, volume, lead time, compensation, screening, and client response. Article 42 explains why timelines vary.
Avoid scorecard mistakes
- Too many measures with no priorities.
- Targets without baseline data.
- Client-controlled metrics assigned only to the provider.
- Different formulas across teams.
- Speed targets that encourage unsafe work.
- Penalties before causes and exclusions are checked.
Run a useful service review
Discuss trends, misses, root causes, worker feedback, risks, and actions. Assign owners and dates. Review targets when volume, sites, shifts, duties, or approvals change.
Connect SLA, agreement, and billing
The agreement should state scope, responsibilities, reporting, changes, escalation, data access, and remedies. Billing should reconcile with approved attendance. Read Article 32 on agreements and Article 37 on billing.
Build a one-page scorecard
Start with five to eight measures that represent capacity, continuity, administration, quality, worker support, and safety. Show current result, target, prior period, trend, cause, and action owner. A red score without an explanation or action is only decoration.
Use one agreed source for each number. Attendance may come from the approved time record, recruitment status from the request tracker, payroll corrections from the help log, and operational quality from the client's system. Reconcile definitions before comparing reports.
Assign shared measures fairly
Some outcomes require both parties. Deployment lead time depends on provider sourcing and client interview speed. Payroll accuracy depends on provider processing and timely client time approval. Replacement time may depend on access badges or client acceptance. A shared KPI should show each dependency rather than assigning all misses to one side.
Use change control
- Record new sites, shifts, duties, volumes, and qualifications.
- Assess effect on recruitment lead time, supervision, training, and price.
- Update KPI baselines and exclusions where necessary.
- Confirm effective date and responsible contacts.
- Retire measures that no longer reflect the service.
Escalate in proportion to risk
A missed report and a safety incident should not follow the same path. Define critical, major, and routine issues with appropriate response times, decision-makers, evidence, and corrective-action review. The aim is rapid control of risk followed by prevention, not blame.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good fill-rate target?
There is no universal target. It should reflect role difficulty, site, shift, volume, lead time, compensation, screening, and client approval.
Which KPIs belong in the contract?
Use fill rate, attendance, replacement, payroll accuracy, issue resolution, training, safety, and role-specific quality measures.
Should every miss have a penalty?
Not necessarily. Where remedies apply, define causes, exclusions, evidence, notice, cure periods, and limits.
How often should performance be reviewed?
Operational issues may need daily or weekly review, while a balanced scorecard is commonly discussed monthly.




